Blog

3D-printed CFRP tools for serial production of composite landing flaps | CompositesWorld

AeroZero TPS, applicable for metals and composites, will protect critical battery housing and parts in the Lilium Jet eVTOL aircraft from burn through and risk of thermal runaway.

V-tail, five-passenger aircraft builds on the vison of the S-A1, designed with a priority on safety and a focus on sustainability. Fish Bone Separator Machine

3D-printed CFRP tools for serial production of composite landing flaps | CompositesWorld

Agreement with green hydrogen producer extended for 2024, investment will support ongoing global capacity expansions including CFRP cylinder production.

Multifunctional four-axis winding system offering fiber flexibility will underpin the NCC’s work in testing and manufacturing pressure vessels leading to commercial production.

The EHang unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) complies with approved type design, safety and quality requirements, with deliveries to customers now underway.

Overair heads to flight testing in early 2024, marked by rapid prototype development. 

The new alliance will broaden National Composites’ capabilities in SMC and BMC and tooling, while providing customers with comprehensive solutions, from initial design to final delivery.

A new ASTM-standardized test method established in 2022 assesses the compression-loaded damage tolerance of sandwich composites.  

Composites automation specialist increases access to next-gen technologies, including novel AFP systems and unique 3D parts using adaptive molds.

Combined LSAM and five-axis CNC milling capabilities will optimize D-Composites’ production services, flexibility and cut time and cost for composite tooling manufacture.

Evaluation of CFRTP m-pipe through Element’s U.K. facility aims to qualify the system for new operating environments.

Innovative prepreg tooling is highly drapable, capable of forming complex carbon fiber tooling shapes, in addition to reducing through thickness porosity and only requiring one debulk during layup.

Novel material to combine Ohoskin’s leather alternative made from orange and cactus byproducts with ReCarbon’s recycled carbon fiber.

Kordsa concludes significant investment aimed at further enhancing its expertise in composites technologies, including development and distribution of more sustainable fiber options to customers.

ST Engineering MRAS discusses the importance of addressing human factors to reduce separator inclusion in bonded structures.

Twenty U.S. teams from 15 states were selected for Phase 1 of funded efforts to develop, mature and commercialize recycling technologies for FRPs and rare earth elements used in wind turbines.

3A Composites Core Materials, STRUCTeam and Beneteau are working to rectify the shortcomings of core requirements of small marine craft in the 2019 framework, while exploring optimal design approaches with foam and balsa core materials.

Maintaining high strength and tensile modulus exceeding 350 GPa has been achieved using Toray’s nano-level structural control technology. 

JEC World 2024: Zünd is highlighting digital excellence via its ZCC Cut Center, heat sealing module (HSM), G3 Cutter and ZPC software.

JEC World 2024: Endless Industries offers 3D printing customers integration of its proprietary printhead, software and fiber filaments to achieve the benefits of lightweight composite parts.

This compact cell brings together 3D printing, AFP and milling aided by a comprehensive software program, further simplifying the manufacture of complex thermoplastic composite aerostructures in the future.

In 2006, guest columnist Bob Hartunian related the story of his efforts two decades prior, while at McDonnell Douglas, to develop a thermoplastic composite crytank for hydrogen storage. He learned a lot of lessons.

Multifunctional four-axis winding system offering fiber flexibility will underpin the NCC’s work in testing and manufacturing pressure vessels leading to commercial production.

Named the NASA Government Invention of the Year, the 3D orthogonally woven materials supports structural and thermal performance needs for Orion mission and more.

CW explores key composite developments that have shaped how we see and think about the industry today.

Knowing the fundamentals for reading drawings — including master ply tables, ply definition diagrams and more — lays a foundation for proper composite design evaluation.

As battery electric and fuel cell electric vehicles continue to supplant internal combustion engine vehicles, composite materials are quickly finding adoption to offset a variety of challenges, particularly for battery enclosure and fuel cell development.  

Performing regular maintenance of the layup tool for successful sealing and release is required to reduce the risk of part adherence.

Increasingly, prototype and production-ready smart devices featuring thermoplastic composite cases and other components provide lightweight, optimized sustainable alternatives to metal.

The composite pressure vessel market is fast-growing and now dominated by demand for hydrogen storage.

The burgeoning advanced air mobility (AAM) market promises to introduce a new mode of transport for urban and intercity travelers — particularly those who wish to bypass the traffic congestion endemic to the world’s largest cities. The electric vertical take-off and landing (eVTOL) aircraft serving this market, because they depend on battery-powered propulsion, also depend on high-strength, high-performance composite structures produced at volumes heretofore unseen in the aerospace composites industry. This CW Tech Days will feature subject matter experts exploring the materials, tooling and manufacturing challenges of ramping up composites fabrication operations to efficiently meet the demands of a challenging and promising new marketplace.

Manufacturers often struggle with production anomalies that can be traced back to material deviations. These can cause fluctuations in material flow, cooling, and cure according to environmental influences and/or batch-to-batch variations. Today’s competitive environment demands cost-efficient, error-free production using automated production and stable processes. As industries advance new bio-based, faster reacting and increased recycled content materials and faster processes, how can manufacturers quickly establish and maintain quality control? In-mold dielectric sensors paired with data analytics technology enable manufacturers to: Determine glass transition temperature in real time Monitor material deviations such as resin mix ratio, aging, and batch-to-batch variations throughout the process Predict the influence of deviations or material defects during the process See the progression of curing and demold the part when the desired degree of cure, Tg or crystallinity is achieved Document resin mix ratios using snap-cure resins for qualification and certification of RTM parts Successful case histories with real parts illustrate how sensXPERT sensors, machine learning, and material models monitor, predict, and optimize production to compensate for deviations. This Digital Mold technology has enabled manufacturers to reduce scrap by up to 50% and generated energy savings of up to 23%. Agenda: Dealing with the challenge of material deviations and production anomalies How dielectric sensors work with different composite resins, fibers and processes What is required for installation Case histories of in-mold dielectric sensors and data analytics used to monitor resin mixing ratios and predict potential material deviations How this Digital Mold technology has enabled manufacturers to optimize production, and improve quality and reliability

SolvaLite is a family of new fast cure epoxy systems that — combined with Solvay's proprietary Double Diaphragm Forming technology — allows short cycle times and reproducibility. Agenda:  Application Development Center and capabilities Solutions for high-rate manufacturing for automotive Application examples: battery enclosures and body panels

OEMs around the world are looking for smarter materials to forward-think their products by combining high mechanical performance with lightweight design and long-lasting durability. In this webinar, composite experts from Exel Composites explain the benefits of a unique continuous manufacturing process for composites profiles and tubes called pull-winding. Pull-winding makes it possible to manufacture strong, lightweight and extremely thin-walled composite tubes and profiles that meet both demanding mechanical specifications and aesthetic needs. The possibilities for customizing the profile’s features are almost limitless — and because pull-winding is a continuous process, it is well suited for high volume production with consistent quality. Join the webinar to learn why you should consider pull-wound composites for your product. Agenda: Introducing pull-winding, and how it compares to other composite manufacturing technologies like filament winding or pultrusion What are the benefits of pull-winding and how can it achieve thin-walled profiles? Practical examples of product challenges solved by pull-winding

Composite systems consist of two sub-constituents: woven fibers as the reinforcement element and resin as the matrix. The most commonly used fibers are glass and carbon, which can be processed in plane or satin structures to form woven fabrics. Carbon fibers, in particular, are known for their high strength/weight properties. Thermoset resins, such as epoxies and polyurethanes, are used in more demanding applications due to their high physical-mechanical properties. However, composites manufacturers still face the challenge of designing the right cure cycles and repairing out-of-shelf-life parts. To address these issues, Alpha Technologies proposes using the encapsulated sample rheometer (premier ESR) to determine the viscoelastic properties of thermosets. Premier ESR generates repeatable and reproducible analytical data and can measure a broad range of viscosity values, making it ideal for resins such as low viscous uncured prepreg or neat resins as well as highly viscous cured prepregs. During testing, before cure, cure and after cure properties can be detected without removing the material from the test chamber. Moreover, ESR can run a broad range of tests, from isothermal and non-isothermal cures to advanced techniques such as large amplitude oscillatory shear tests. During this webinar, Alpha Technologies will be presenting some of the selected studies that were completed on epoxy prepreg systems utilizing ESR and how it solves many issues in a fast and effective way. It will highlight the advantages of this technique that were proven with the work of several researchers. Moreover, Alpha Technologies will display part of these interesting findings using the correlations between the viscoelastic properties such as G’ and mechanical properties such as short beam shear strength (SBS).

Surface preparation is a critical step in composite structure bonding and plays a major role in determining the final bonding performance. Solvay has developed FusePly, a breakthrough technology that offers the potential to build reliable and robust bonded composite parts through the creation of covalently-bonded structures at bondline interface. FusePly technology meets the manufacturing challenges faced by aircraft builders and industrial bonding users looking for improved performance, buildrates and lightweighting. In this webinar, you will discover FusePly's key benefits as well as processing and data. Agenda: Surface preparation challenges for composite bonding FusePly technology overview Properties and performance data

The annual Conference on Composites, Materials, and Structures (also known as the Cocoa Beach Conference) is the preeminent export controlled and ITAR restricted forum in the United States to review and discuss advances in materials for extreme environments. The Conference started in the 1970s as a small informal gathering for government and industry to share information on programs and state-of-the-art technology. Attendance has grown to nearly 500 people while preserving this same objective to share needs and trends in high-temperature and extreme environment materials, and the latest information on advanced materials and manufacturing processes. The five-day conference program includes two to three parallel sessions per day on topics including thermal protection materials, ceramic matrix composites, carbon-carbon materials, ballistic technologies, hypersonics, and gas turbine engines. Attendees are engineers, scientists, managers, and operational personnel from the turbine engine, aviation, missiles and space, and protective equipment communities. These communities include the Navy, Air Force, Army, MDA, NASA, DARPA, FAA, DOE, engine manufacturers, missile and aircraft manufacturers, commercial space companies, and material and component suppliers. The Conference will be held in St. Augustine again for 2024! Participation is limited to U.S. Citizens and U.S. Permanent Residents only with an active DD2345 certification.

The 48th International Conference & Exposition on Advanced Ceramics & Composites (ICACC 2024) will be held from Jan. 28–Feb. 2, 2024, in Daytona Beach, Fla. It is a great honor to chair this conference, which has a strong history of being one of the best international meetings on advanced structural and functional ceramics, composites, and other emerging ceramic materials and technologies.

Venue ONLY ON-SITE @AZL Hub in Aachen Building Part 3B, 4th Floor Campus Boulevard 30 52074 Aachen Time: January 31st, 2024 | 11:00-16:00h (CET) This first constitutive session will shape the future of the workgroup. ✓ Insights into solutions for e.g. circularity, recycling, sustainability, end of life etc. ✓ Interactive exchange along the value chain to tackle these challenges: Share your input in the “World Café” workshop session! ✓ Are you a solution provider? Take your chance and present your solution approach in a short 5-minute pitch. Get in touch with Alexander.  

The Transformative Vertical Flight (TVF) 2024 meeting will take place Feb. 6–8, 2024 in Santa Clara, California, in the heart of Silicon Valley and will feature more than 100 speakers on important progress on vertical takeoff and landing (VTOL) aircraft and technology. 

The EPTA – European Pultrusion Technology Association in cooperation with the American Composites Manufacturers Association (ACMA) invites you to the 17th World Pultrusion Conference which takes place on 29 February – 1 March 2024 in Hamburg, Germany. Visit the most important event in Europe in the market for pultruded fiber reinforced materials  This conference takes place every two years and is the meeting point of the European and worldwide Pultrusion Industry. More than 25 international speakers from Finland, Belgium, Germany, France, Spain, The Netherlands, Turkey, UK, USA, Canada and others will present practical presentations about innovative applications, technologies and processes. Equally current market trends and developments are on the agenda. This World Pultrusion Conference takes place again in the week before the JEC World Composites Show (5-7 March 2024, Paris). The presentation language will be English. Please finde here the full program and booking opportunities. We appreciate very much welcoming you in Hamburg! Inquiries should be requested by email: info@pultruders.com

The Program of this Summit consists of a range of 12 high-level lectures by 14 invited speakers only. Topics are composite related innovations in Automotive & Transport, Space & Aerospace, Advanced Materials, and Process Engineering, as well as Challenging Applications in other markets like Architecture, Construction, Sports, Energy, Marine & more.

Thousands of people visit our Supplier Guide every day to source equipment and materials. Get in front of them with a free company profile.

Jetcam’s latest white paper explores the critical aspects of nesting in composites manufacturing, and strategies to balance material efficiency and kitting speed.

Arris presents mechanical testing results of an Arris-designed natural fiber thermoplastic composite in comparison to similarly produced glass and carbon fiber-based materials.

Cevotec, a tank manufacturer, Roth Composite Machinery and Cikoni, have undertaken a comprehensive project to explore and demonstrate the impact of dome reinforcements using FPP technology for composite tanks.   

Initial demonstration in furniture shows properties two to nine times higher than plywood, OOA molding for uniquely shaped components.

The composite tubes white paper explores some of the considerations for specifying composite tubes, such as mechanical properties, maintenance requirements and more.

Foundational research discusses the current carbon fiber recycling landscape in Utah, and evaluates potential strategies and policies that could enhance this sustainable practice in the region.

The three-year strategic collaboration will help boost the company’s growth, reinforce its commitments to become carbon neutral by 2040 and innovate more circular chemicals and materials.

Oak Ridge National Laboratory's Sustainable Manufacturing Technologies Group helps industrial partners tackle the sustainability challenges presented by fiber-reinforced composite materials.

Eco-friendly carbon fiber slashes carbon footprint by half through renewable energy, a commitment echoed in SGL’s Lavradio biomass plant set to reduce CO2 emissions by 90,000 tons.  

JEC World 2024: Flax fiber producer Groupe Depestele and sustainable composites company Greenboats demonstrate flax fiber materials, demonstrators and product offer Circular Structures.

Acrylonitrile to be used in Tenax uses waste and residue from biomass-derived products or recycled raw materials that are ISCC Plus certified, maintaining same performance properties as conventional-based products.

JEC World 2024: Swancor demonstrates its EzCiclo recyclable epoxy and recycling process in wind, sporting goods and automotive applications.

The composites industry is increasingly recognizing the imperative of sustainability in its operations. As demand for lightweight and durable materials rises across various sectors, such as automotive, aerospace, and construction, there is a growing awareness of the environmental impact associated with traditional composite manufacturing processes.

This CW Tech Days event will explore the technologies, materials, and strategies that can help composites manufacturers become more sustainable.

During CW Tech Days: Thermoplastics for Large Structures, experts explored the materials and processing technologies that are enabling the transition to large-part manufacturing.

Explore the cutting-edge composites industry, as experts delve into the materials, tooling, and manufacturing hurdles of meeting the demands of the promising advanced air mobility (AAM) market. Join us at CW Tech Days to unlock the future of efficient composites fabrication operations.

CompositesWorld’s CW Tech Days: Infrastructure event offers a series of expert presentations on composite materials, processes and applications that should and will be considered for use in the infrastructure and construction markets.

In the Automated Composites Knowledge Center, CGTech brings you vital information about all things automated composites.

Closed mold processes offer many advantages over open molding. This knowledge center details the basics of closed mold methods and the products and tools essential to producing a part correctly.

CW’s editors are tracking the latest trends and developments in tooling, from the basics to new developments. This collection, presented by Composites One, features four recent CW stories that detail a range of tooling technologies, processes and materials.

CompositesWorld’s CW Tech Days: Infrastructure event offers a series of expert presentations on composite materials, processes and applications that should and will be considered for use in the infrastructure and construction markets.

Explore the cutting-edge composites industry, as experts delve into the materials, tooling, and manufacturing hurdles of meeting the demands of the promising advanced air mobility (AAM) market. Join us at CW Tech Days to unlock the future of efficient composites fabrication operations.

Thermoplastics for Large Structures, experts explored the materials and processing technologies that are enabling the transition to large-part manufacturing.

Explore the technologies, materials, and strategies that can help composites manufacturers become more sustainable.

A report on the demand for hydrogen as an energy source and the role composites might play in the transport and storage of hydrogen.

This collection features detail the current state of the industry and recent success stories across aerospace, automotive and rail applications.

This collection details the basics, challenges, and future of thermoplastic composites technology, with particular emphasis on their use for commercial aerospace primary structures.

This collection features recent CW stories that detail a range of tooling technologies, processes and materials.

GKN Aerospace Munich and CEAD develop printed tooling with short and continuous fiber that reduces cost and increases sustainability for composites production.

Replacing hand layup BMI intensifier tools. Intensifier tools used in serial production of A350 landing flaps were 3D printed with short carbon fiber-reinforced thermoplastic for the stringer-stiffened CFRP lower cover (tools, top left) and upper cover (tools, bottom right), also shown demolded on top of a flap cover after 180°C autoclave cure (top right). The ATLAM print head using continuous fiber (bottom left) has been developed for tools longer than 1.5 meters. Photo Credit: GKN Aerospace Deutschland, TU Munich LCC and CEAD

The light weight and durable high performance of carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (CFRP) parts is increasingly necessary to achieve aviation goals for reduced emissions. A key challenge, however, is the tooling required to mold these materials into high-quality, shaped and integrated parts such as stringer-stiffened skins. Such tools must deliver tight tolerances during high-temperature molding processes for hundreds of cycles with a thermal expansion that either matches that of CFRP parts or is managed via compensation.

In 2017, tooling was described as 3D printing’s “killer app,” offering significant reductions in lead time, material cost and manual labor. And yet, 3D-printed tools are not yet common in serial production of high-temperature, autoclave-cured parts for aerospace. However, a project started in 2019 produced 17 tools printed with short carbon fiber (CF)-reinforced thermoplastic by CEAD (Delft, Netherlands) that have been used for more than two years by GKN Aerospace in Munich, Germany, for the serial production of CFRP landing flaps for Airbus (Toulouse, France) A350 aircraft.

The team, which also includes the Technical University of Munich (TU Munich, Germany) Chair of Carbon Composites (LCC), moved a step further in 2023, unveiling the advanced tape layer additive manufacturing (ATLAM) printhead that combines continuous CF tapes with the previously used short CF materials to achieve the lower coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) necessary for tools longer than 1.5 meters. In fact, several dozen tools used in GKN Munich’s flap production are longer than 1.5 meters, and the team is now demonstrating how to use ATLAM for their production.

Image illustrated by Susan Kraus. 

GKN Aerospace (Solihull, U.K.) is a well-known Tier 1 engine systems and aerostructures manufacturer and composites innovator. Its GKN Deutschland subsidiary in Munich supplies CFRP landing flaps for the Airbus A330 and A350 widebody aircraft. Attached to the wing’s trailing edge, landing flaps are actuated to increase the wing’s surface area and camber during takeoff and landing.

For the A350 landing flaps, which are 1.6 meters wide and 7-8 meters long depending on the specific A350 model, GKN Munich manufactures CFRP stringer-stiffened upper and lower covers for the left and right wings. These require dozens of different-sized track intensifier tools, used for areas without stringers where attachments will be made. Track intensifiers (see Fig. 2) span the width of the flap covers and are used where actuation-enabling flap tracks and cross-span stiffening ribs will be attached.

GKN Munich had traditionally made track intensifier tools using hand layup of CF/bismaleimide (BMI) tooling prepreg or conventional epoxy tooling prepreg on machined aluminum master tools. The layups were autoclave cured at 180-218°C and 7 bar of pressure in two to three stages, followed by machining of the outer 3D curved surface to a tolerance of ±0.1 millimeter.

“The process for curing the BMI tools is complicated, requiring a hot pressure debulk [HPD], a cure and post-cure cycle and also a cure cycle for the two-component epoxy wear coating,” says Frank Strachauer, project leader and R&D engineer at GKN Munich. “These tools had high material and production costs and a long lead time for manufacturing. The process was expensive, requiring significant labor time, including a lot of manual work for the bagging, and it also consumed a huge amount of auxiliary materials. The lead times were also quite long — up to several weeks for fabrication plus a minimum of 3 months for production of the metal master tools in advance.”

“3D printing offers a more efficient digital production,” he continues. “It would be a new and innovative approach for intensifiers, with potential for a large reduction in lead time and cost. It would also simplify the whole process flow for tooling, increase our production flexibility and enable recycling of the production waste and, eventually, the tools themselves.” GKN’s customer, Airbus, has been an associated partner in the resulting projects to develop this technology.

CEAD is a pioneer in extrusion-based, large-format AM. Founded in 2014, it began development with continuous fibers in 2017. By 2019, it had commercialized its standalone robot extruders, its gantry-based, 4 × 2 × 1.5-meter continuous fiber additive manufacturing (CFAM) Prime machine and six-axis robotic Flexbot. It added milling capability to Flexbot by 2020 and announced its partnership with Belotti (Suisio, Italy) for very large CNC systems in 2021.

To begin developing the 3D printing process for intensifier tools, GKN Munich worked with CEAD to conduct a long list of printed material tests to assess strength, thermal expansion and fatigue, machinability, vacuum tightness, repairability, etc. They chose short CF/polyethersulfone (PESU) due to its glass transition temperature (Tg), which is above 200°C and thus compatible with the 180°C cure aerospace-grade epoxy prepreg for the CFRP landing flap covers.

The next step was to design the printed parts. “For the first set of prototype tools, we were using our smallest machine,” says CEAD CTO and cofounder, Maarten Logtenberg. “So, the team chose to print a full set of track intensifiers, due to their size, up to 0.6 × 1.6 meters.” These tools had a final machined thickness of 6-10 millimeters and included joggles to match the ply ramps and drop-offs in each flap cover skin.

CEAD designed the printed parts to combine left-hand and right-hand wing tools, which were then split in half and machined to final surface quality and dimensions. Photo Credit: CEAD

“We then went into this sort of development cycle, to come up with how to print all of the different intensifiers in a way that we’d have a high success rate,” says Logtenberg. “We designed the printed parts to combine both left-hand [LH] and right-hand [RH] wing tools in the same complex-shaped, closed contours, which allowed continuous printing.” Eight printed parts produced all four intensifiers — End Rib, Rib 1, Track 1 and Track 2 — for the upper and lower flap covers for LH and RH wings. After printing, the closed contour parts were split in half and then machined.

Figure 1. Printed beads, machined tools. CEAD software enables modeling the print beads (gray) together with the final, machined part (green) to verify sufficient material is available for machining the printed parts to the final surface and dimensions required for the production tools. Photo Credit: CEAD

The printed parts were slightly oversized, ensuring the additional material required for machining to the final surface quality and tolerances. “We were able to improve our slicing and printing simulation software so that we have the capability to offset any surface a certain amount,” explains CEAD software engineer Jasper Klein Mentink, “and then view a model of the print beads together with the final part [Fig. 1]. In this way, we can precisely verify whether there is sufficient material to remove to achieve the final product dimensions. The software can quickly iterate designs and helps us to ensure prints are ‘first time right,’ which saves a lot of time and material. Additionally, the printed bead model can be imported into CAM software to aid the milling process.”

“The 3D printing process for the initial set of intensifier tools was very fast,” says Logtenberg, “between 160 and 420 minutes for each of the eight parts depending on its size and complexity. The milling, however, was a bit of a challenge, as we didn’t have in-house capability at that time, and had to rely on an outside company. But it worked out and we successfully completed the first full set of prototype intensifiers.”

There were important lessons learned as well. “During the production of the first set of track intensifiers, it became apparent that the printing process and subsequent machining caused material distortions due to internal stress,” says Strachauer. “This can be countered by printing with sufficient oversize to allow the residual distortion in machining to be removed. In addition, the milling tools, milling parameters and a correctly selected and part-adapted milling strategy also play a decisive role in achieving exact dimensional accuracy of the tools.”

GKN Munich used this set of 3D-printed track intensifier tools to produce full-sized test flap covers in mid-2019. The resulting CFRP parts passed all required quality checks, including microscopic void analysis and ultrasonic inspection to validate the laminate thickness and quality.

Figure. 2. Two years in autoclave parts production. Qualified 3D-printed track intensifier tools, shown here demolded from a flap lower cover after autoclave cure, were implemented into GKN Munich’s serial production of landing flaps starting in early 2021. Photo Credit: GKN Deutschland

After completing qualification of the 3D-printed intensifier tools, GKN implemented them in serial production of A350 landing flaps in early 2021 (Fig. 2). The tools have now been in use for more than two years.

“This is groundbreaking for the industry,” says Strachauer. “We were able to show a major cost reduction and lead time reduction versus the previous tooling. We have also eliminated the need for master tools, autoclave cure and manual layup. The 3D printed intensifier tools have shown increased accuracy and quality due to a fully automated printing and machining process.” He also notes their thermoplastic construction enables repair and recycling options not possible with the previous thermoset-based systems.

However, the 3D-printed tools fell short in one area. “We did a lot of research with GKN and TU Munich in terms of thermal expansion,” says Logtenberg, “and we discovered that up to roughly 1.5 meters in length, you can print the tooling without any continuous fiber — so, just extrusion of short fiber-reinforced pellets. But for tools longer than 1.5 meters, the CTE is too large, and it becomes difficult to compensate for the thermal expansion.” Note, more than 80% of the tools GKN Munich uses to produce the outboard landing flaps are longer than 1.5 meters.

“We knew we could reduce the CTE by using continuous fiber,” says Logtenberg, “and we already had quite a lot of experience with continuous fiber printing through our CFAM technology.” CFAM combines chopped and continuous fiber materials inside the 3D printing nozzle. “So, our first prototypes for longer tools were based on that as well. But due to the high processing temperatures of the thermoplastics needed to withstand autoclave cure and the high modulus of the continuous carbon fiber, it was difficult to achieve the right impregnation of the material with the quality and reliability required for aerospace tools.”

Even though CEAD used the same matrix material for continuous fiber unidirectional (UD) tapes and short fiber pellets, the optimal processing conditions for each were different. “For example, you could be within the required temperature range for the matrix, but the tape would be too soft, while the extrusion material was not hot enough,” explains Logtenberg. “We were continuously struggling with how to manage the process. Finally, we came up with the idea to separate the material processes. They are still combined as we move the print head, but we first extrude the short fiber layer and the pre-impregnated tape with the continuous fiber comes right after. This gives us full control of processing the tape as well as extrusion of the short fiber material.” This is the ATLAM process and print head.

“Once we were able to prove the feasibility, GKN established a public-funded research project,” says Logtenberg. TU Munich was also included, performing research in thermal expansion, laminate quality and voids. Also involved was machining technology firm Hufschmied (Bobingen, Germany), exploring how to machine the printed raw parts.

In 2021, GKN Munich and CEAD submitted patent applications, worked through 2022 to further refine the equipment and printed the first proof of concept tooling parts in early 2023. “This development has taken two years,” says Logtenberg, “but we have finally succeeded in a reliable process that enables large-scale autoclave tools with a sufficiently low CTE.” Strachauer further details: “It is close to Invar in the print direction and the same value compared to BMI tooling prepreg.”

Figure 3. ATLAM for lower CTE, longer printed tools.  The ATLAM process and print head extrudes short fiber thermoplastic material followed immediately by continuous fiber tape, achieving a sufficiently low CTE to enable autoclave curing tools longer than 1.5 meters. Shown here is the first 2.2-meter-long part for GKN Munich U-intensifier tools, 3D printed using ATLAM at TU Munich. Photo Credit: GKN Deutschland, TU Munich LCC.

CEAD officially launched ATLAM at JEC World 2023 (April 25-27, Paris, France), where it showed a third-generation ATLAM print head, says Logtenberg. “Every iteration represents a significant improvement, and we will continue advancing the technology. We have designed ATLAM with sensors and control possibilities that TU Munich uses to measure the impact of process parameters on the finished print CTE, modulus, voids, etc. They want to nail down what the best processing parameters are for various material options. Meanwhile, we are mounting ATLAM on our next generation of robots in-house so that we can start producing sample parts.”

Will these next prints include some of the longer intensifier tools for GKN Munich? “We’re working on that now,” says Logtenberg. There are also other options. For example, Airtech International (Huntington Beach, Calif., U.S.) is 3D printing large-scale tools as part of its Tooling of Tomorrow (TOT) business. It has dedicated 3D printing facilities in Springfield, Tennessee, and Luxembourg, Europe, as part of its vision to advance AM composites through its technical expertise and Dahltram 3D printing resins.

“We’re already talking about how we can continue to strengthen our collaboration with Airtech,” says Logtenberg, “because we’re using a lot of their 3D printing resins, which are good materials that work very well in our machines.”

“We are also looking for two or three other research partners to implement ATLAM,” he adds, “because there is still more research needed. This market is difficult for new technologies to be adopted and fully utilized. So, it’s important to show what can be done with ATLAM, using various materials and combinations of short fiber and continuous fiber layers, to explore the possible solutions that can be achieved. And we still have some challenges to tackle, such as the software for programming toolpaths, because ATLAM is entirely different than anything that’s out there right now.”

For GKN Munich, the 3D-printed track intensifier tools and upcoming U-intensifiers printed with continuous fiber represent two stages of its AM roadmap for fiber-reinforced thermoplastic composites. “This is only the beginning of a new era of 3D-printed tooling for high-temperature autoclave curing of structural composite parts at GKN Aerospace,” says Strachauer. “We will also look at producing layup tooling and expand to other families of tooling as we move toward developing structural parts printed with continuous fiber. Additive manufacturing at GKN Aerospace — across both engines and aerostructures technology — is being expanded all the time to open new applications and new markets.”

Logtenberg agrees. “Additive manufacturing will become better and more mature every year, as we are seeing with new support and materials from companies like Airtech and new developments in software, which will enable new capabilities. I think the work we have done with GKN Munich and TU Munich has helped set us apart and positioned us to help create such new technologies. We are growing and the market for additive manufactured composites is still growing — every day we learn about new applications and see the opportunities they open for the future.”

Fast-reacting resins and speedier processes are making economical volume manufacturing possible.

Manned deepsea exploration calls for a highly engineered composites solution that saves weight and preserves life — at 6,500-psi service pressure.

The emerging H2 economy drives tank development for aircraft, ships and gas transport.

The structural properties of composite materials are derived primarily from the fiber reinforcement. Fiber types, their manufacture, their uses and the end-market applications in which they find most use are described.

Hybrid thermoset/thermoplastic composite part with 3D-printed functionalization demonstrates technology possibilities and EmpowerAX open platform offering expertise from members throughout the process chain.

Anybrid’s ROBIN demonstrates inline/offline functionalization of profiles, 3D-printed panels and bio-based materials for more efficient, sustainable composite parts.

Toolmakers and molders continue to realize the benefits of additive versus conventional/subtractive manufacturing of molds and mold components.  

3D-printed CFRP tools for serial production of composite landing flaps | CompositesWorld

Retort Sterilizer CompositesWorld is the source for reliable news and information on what’s happening in fiber-reinforced composites manufacturing. Learn More